Early publications resembling yearbooks included Fond Recollections (1891-?), Class of Ninety-Six (1896), and The Earlhamite Annual (1902, 1907-1908).

Consecutive annuals began in 1906 with the publication of the Sargasso (1906, 1909-2008). The last print edition was made in 2002. It was released on DVD from 2003-2008 without a print version. The yearbooks were not made after 2008.

Non-circulating copies of the Sargasso are available in the Earlham Archives and circulating copies are available in the Earlham Lilly Library Main Collection.

The call number for Lilly Library's copy of the Sargasso is: LD1741.E45 The call number for the Archive's copy of the Sargasso is: Archives LD1741.E45.